Book Review: Lessons From a Dead Girl

Lessons From a Dead Girl

Jo Knowles

Candlewick

224 pages

You know what it’s like to read a lackluster book?  You know, the type of book that you didn’t dislike–it just meant nothing to you at all?  I had that type of experience with Lessons From a Dead Girl, with Jo Knowles–just completely lackluster.  I was unable to connect with the book in any way, which to me is a fate worse than actually hating a book!  It just feels like such a waste of time to read a book and then be left empty afterward.

Lessons From a Dead Girl is the story of Leah and Laine.  It begins with Leah’s death while the two are in high school, and then goes back and retraces their tumultuous friendship.  Originally, I picked up the book because the description referred to some type of sexual abuse or sexual situation going on between Leah and Laine, and that interested me on a level of sheer curiosity.  In reading the book, it becomes obvious that Leah is the leader in the friendship which causes resentment on Lainey’s end and eventually leads to a fissure in the relationship.

One thing I did appreciate with this book is the way Knowles began with Leah’s death and then went back to the beginning and worked her way up to Leah’s demise.  Having know nothing about Leah and Laine’s friendship when I began the book, I eventually had to go back and read the first portion of the book once I had finished the story.  It was fun to see how my perception had changed once I knew Laine’s version of events.

As to why I was unable to connect with the book, I don’t have much of an explanation.  It isn’t a bad book.  I wouldn’t try to discourage others from reading it–it just wasn’t for me.  I think part of the problem is that I have been feeling burnt out on YA fiction within the last few weeks, so the YA fiction I’ve read in that span seems to have been affected by my mood shift.

Other revies:

The Book Zombie

A Chair, a Fireplace & a Tea Cozy

Becky’s Book Reviews

I borrowed this book from my local library
Advertisements

3 Responses

  1. […] the article here: Book Review: Lessons From a Dead Girl « ReviewsbyLola's Blog Tags: discourage-others, feeling-burnt, from-reading, last-few, problem, the-problem, […]

  2. I’ve read books before when I wasn’t in the right mood and had them turn out lackluster like this. I mean, sometimes it’s the book, but sometimes it’s my mood, too. I’m actually really looking forward to this particular book. I hope i like it better. But I’m actually a bit burnt out on YA right now, too, so I haven’t been reading very much of it in the last two months.

  3. I’m sad to hear this. I had hopes that this would be really interesting. Guess it will go way down the tbr list – there are too many books that people love that I want to get to.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s