Book Review: Paper Towns

s3jKcKqzhoj1r2la6h8YuZ6Ko1_400Paper Towns

John Green

Audiobook

8 hours

Let me start off by saying I really loathe this cover.  On its own, it is fine, but when I realize it is supposed to be Margo Roth Spiegelman, I’m not a happy camper.  That is not how I picture her in my head AT ALL.  So I prefer the cover with the map and the pushpin on it.  But anyway . . .

Paper Towns is the story of Quentin “Q” Jacobsen.  Q is part of the nerdier crowd.  He used to, as a child, play with his neighbor, Margo Roth Speigelman, but she has moved onto the more popular crowd so Q must watch her from afar.  Until one night a few weeks prior to their high school graduation.  Margo has discovered that her boyfriend has been cheating on her with her best friend.  Not only that–she believes that her other best friend, Lacey, has been in on the secret and purposely keeping it from Margo.  So Margo decides to seek revenge.

Margo shows up at Q’s window one night in full black face paint and requests that Q escort her on her revenge mission.  Q aquiesces and the two spend a long night playing over the top pranks as well as breaking into Sea World.  Q wakes up the next morning itching to get to school so he can see Margo, but she never shows.  Turns out she’s gone.  Q is convinced she’s left clues for him so he tirelessly tries to discover her whereabouts.

The synopsis above probably sounds trite.  Unfortunately, I couldn’t convey it in the way I wanted to, because this book is anything but trite.  It is one of the most thought provoking YA novels I’ve ever read–in fact, I would say it read more like an adult novel.  From the start of her disappearance, Margo is an enigma.  We get all these glimpses of her from different people–her parents, Q, Lacey . . . and all seem vastly different.  The reader really starts to question the idea of perception.  The way I see myself may not be how she sees me or he sees me, etc. etc.  This idea is really driven home during the end of the book.  Unfortunately, by that time, I was admitedly getting a little annoyed with the book.  The first few chapters, with agloe164-highlight-300x269Q and Margo on there one night adventure was stunning–some of the best fiction I have read all year.  But then Margo disappears.  And Q starts looking for her.  And you think he’s discovered her.  And then he hasn’t.  But then maybe he has.  But he hasn’t.  The whole thing became very repetative to me and I ended up getting bored with the story.

There is, however, a lot to be gained by listening to the book on audio.  Margo is awesome.  I fell in love with her right away.  The narrator was a man, but he was able to convey Margo’s voice in a way that worked well for me and I loved listening to his rendition of her.  Radar and Ben, Q’s two best friends, really shone through as well on the narration.  They added a comic element that really spiced things up.

As much as I loved Margo at the beginning of the book, I wasn’t too sure about those feelings by the time the book ended.  Did I like her or did I not?  And if I didn’t like her, was that really any fault of her own?  Or was it because she didn’t live up to my expectations?  It was almost as if I myself became a character in the book.  I felt like I had invested almost as much as the others had in their search for her.

I haven’t read Green’s other books yet, although I plan to.  I’ll be interested to see how they compare to Paper Towns.

Other reviews:

Fizzy Thoughts

Teen Book Review

Things Mean a Lot

Book Addiction

Young Adult (and Kids) Books Central Blog

Liv’s Book Reviews

Look at That Book

Becky’s Book Review

Dreadlock Girl

Em’s Bookshelf

Just Listen Book Reviews

The Book Pirate

il primo

YAnnabe

Au Courant

Confessions of a Bibliovore

Casual Dread

Fyrefly’s Book Blog

YA Reads

Random Thoughts From a Random Teen

Reader Rabbit

Regular Rumination

Book-Lover Carol

And Another Book Read

Harmony Book Reviews

Bookshelves of Doom

Advertisements

5 Responses

  1. Looking for Alaska is much better than Abundance of Katherines, imo. So you should read that one next. 😀

    I go back and forth w/ prefering this book, or Alaska, as my favorite of Green’s books. The road trip in this one was just fantastic. If you do read Alaska, don’t read about it beforehand!

  2. I have this one in hardcover format w/ sad Margo & I don’t like the cover at all. I agree w/ you-the paperback cover is much better! Anyway, this’ll be my second Green book-I really enjoyed Looking for Alaska!

  3. I have got to get this book! I keep putting it off because I really need to read the books I own, but I keep hearing wonderful things.

  4. You liked Margo, hmm? I could not understand her. I did, however, enjoy Green’s writing, and I hope to read Looking for Alaska.

  5. […] Paper Towns, John Green (audio) […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s